7 replies to this topic

[GRADUATE]

Hi all,

 

I am working on a gap analysis between ISO 22K against BRC and IFS for a bakery.

 

Has anyone already done one or can they guide me in right direction as to where and how to start this?

 

Also ISO 22k has clause 4.1 & 4.2, which are not in any of the other standards (BRC & IFS) from my perspective, however, if anyone thinks differently please advise?

 

Many thanks

 

Ankit

[Utama]

Helllo...

 

I think you can start with a breakdown each clause of that all regulation.

and start reviewing and discuss it from clause 4 to the related dept

[GRADUATE]

Hi RafifutamaPutra,

 

Thank you for the help, I have started on it already however ISO 22K clause 4.1 and 4.2 are not included in any other clauses, does anyone have any clue what does these clause means?

 

Thank you

[Utama]

4.1 The Organizations and its Context, it is like a SWOT Organizations analysis (Internal Issue & External Issue)

 

4.2 The need and expectations of interest parties are like Context organization, need & expectation related parties.

 

Both of that clauses usually use the document "Risks & Opportunities"

[Charles.C]

Hi all,

 

I am working on a gap analysis between ISO 22K against BRC and IFS for a bakery.

 

Has anyone already done one or can they guide me in right direction as to where and how to start this?

 

Also ISO 22k has clause 4.1 & 4.2, which are not in any of the other standards (BRC & IFS) from my perspective, however, if anyone thinks differently please advise?

 

Many thanks

 

Ankit

Hi Graduate,

 

Yr initial request is known as a cross-matrix.

 

These used to be in common use but the problem was/is they need updating quite frequently so are now less available. AFAIK there is no matrix for current versions of standards you mention.

 

Iso-haccp is rather different to BRC/IFS (Codex) haccp and the philosophy/operational structure of iso22000 is semi-borrowed from iso9001.

Regarding 4.1/4.2, the document attached may help overview yr request but lacks specific examples. The latter do exist within sub-forum iso22000 if you search a bit.

 

 Guidance_ISO-22000-Interpretation (ex FSSC22000).pdf   666.91KB   65 downloads

 

 

 

 

[GRADUATE]

Thank you Charles, I have completed the cross referencing between ISO22 and BRC and now working on ISO22k and IFS.

 

Once completed if anyone interested I can share the document here.

 

Many thanks

 

Ankit

[Charles.C]

Thank you Charles, I have completed the cross referencing between ISO22 and BRC and now working on ISO22k and IFS.

 

Once completed if anyone interested I can share the document here.

 

Many thanks

 

Ankit

Hi Ankit,

 

FWIW, these cross-matrix links/threads were relevant several years back and might be of limited interest -

 

https://www.ifsqn.co...-v6/#entry86909

(Italian,BRC6 vs IFS6,excel)

 

https://www.ifsqn.co...-v6/#entry87004

(English as per previous but in .docx)

 

I also found this BRC4 vs iso22000(2005) vs IFS4 vs etc in my archives which is a truly amazing cross-matrix but goes back ca 13 years -

 

 cargill - cross-matrix,Multi-Comparison FS Standards ca 2010.xls   72.5KB   38 downloads

 

For a slightly different format style (sort of reversed) can see this (probably) BRC6 vs IFS6 model -

https://techni-k.co....safety-ifs-food

 

ISO22000's close relationship to iso9001 (2008 era) is illustrated in this nicely formatted file -

 

https://www.ifsqn.co...e-5/#entry33194

 

PS - Yes, would be much appreciated if you can upload yr finished documents. Maybe get some free comments also !

[RobiWanKenobi]

Hello World,

just took a look into this thread as I am supposed to set up a gap analysis betweeen IFS Food v8 and BRCGS Food v9.

Online I found a made up checklist of IFS v7tov8 and next to it BRCGS v8tov9 so I simply consolidated them into one. When I am done to implement newest doctrines or other things to it, i can put it here if someone wants to. Finding the Gaps is easy that way.

 

kr

Robert